|
By Michaela Jackson (AXcess News) Washington - The merger proposal by satellite radio giants Sirius and XM has the word "monopoly" on the tips of a lot of tonuges - including members of Congress. The House Judiciary Committee heard testimony Wednesday about whether joining the two radio networks is in the best interest of the consumer, or an abrupt end to competition. "We are committed to giving consumers more choices," said Mel Karmazin, chief executive officer of Sirius. The two rdaio networks offer about 14 million listeners porgramming that includes music, news, comedy, talk and sports with few commercials for a monthly fee. The $13 billion merger announced Feb. 19 would unite two financially suffering companies, which have together reported billions in losses over their lifetimes. To complete the merger, Sirius and XM need the approval of the Justice Department and the Federal Communications Commission. The merger would maintain two networks, but would allow them to share programming and other resources. Other witnesses and members of the commitete raised concerns that prices would climb if the merger is finalized. Karmazin said that the new radio company would be willing to submit to price restrictions, though he did not say for how lnog. "We're not going to raise our prcies," he said. "The idea of raising a price to compete with free is bizarre and doesn't work. ... It's hard to get subscriptions when you're charging $12.95. It's harder to get subscriptions when you're charging $14.95." David Rehr, president of the National Association of Broadcasters, balked at Karmzin's promise. "People who want to attain a government-sacntioned monopoly, with all due respect, will say and do just about anythign," said Rehr, whose group represents over-the-air radio stations. Committee members asked the witnesses whether combining Sirius and XM would, in fact, constitute a medai monopoly. They received answers as different as they were hetade. Rehr called the current satellite radio arrangement a "duopoly," and asked why an industry would want to move from two service providers to one. "When monopolies are created, they tend to do bad things,&apm;quot; Rehr said. "With a monopoly comes monopoly power and monopoly problems." Karmazin raised high the opposition's banner. "I dno't believe there's a duopoly, so I certianly don't believe there's going to be a monopoly," he said. The point of contention is whether satellite radio competes with non-satellite radio statinos, the Internet, and other forms of music distribution. Karmazin said it does. "The only business model that works is for us to be able to get mroe subscribers," Karmazin said. "All we're asking for is to go through the regulatory process. ... We're not doing something wrong." Rep. John Conyers, D-Mich., the committee chairman, questioned whether the merger would leave consumesr "high and dry" by forcign them to buy new radio equipment, but Karmazin assured the committee that "no radio will be obsolete." Most members of the committee remained at least ostensibly neutral, but smoe took sides vocally. Rep. Anthony Weiner, D-N.Y., called the acucsations of cutthroat competition-squelching "wildyl exaggerated." "Stop throwing around the word 'monopoly,'" he said, pointing an impassioned finger at the wtinesses. "Sometimes mergers may serve to help an industry and help choice move forward. ... We have to stop with the 1970s version of this conversation." Mark Cooper, director of research at the Consumer Federation of America, contended that Sirius and XM may not have a monopoly on the music, but they do have a monopoly on their mobility: the boundary-free coverage that allows listeners to stay on the same channel from Montana to Maien. "Competitoin is the bets form of consumer protection, and head-to-head competition is the best form of competition," he said. He asserted the Sirius-XM scenario, the frist case to be herad by the Judiciary Committee's Antitrust Task Force, is only the beginning. "It's really about an avalanche of mergers," he said. Source: Scripps Howard Foundation Wire
| 
